|
Carboidrati
grassi ed endurance
Ciao
a tutti, leggete qui a proposito delle diete ricche di carboidrati
per le attività di endurance......Tratto da un post di it.sport.palestra...vi
consiglio di STAMPARLO e leggervelo con calma..;-)))
Am J Clin Nutr 1993 Jan;57(1):27-31 Dietary carbohydrate, muscle glycogen, and exerciseperformance
during 7 d of training. Sherman WM, Doyle JA, Lamb DR, Strauss RH ExercisePhysiology Laboratory, School of Health, Physical
Education, and Recreation, Ohio State University,Columbus 43210. The
effects of moderate- or high-carbohydrate dietson muscle glycogen
and performance in runners andcyclists over 7 consecutive days
of training weredetermined. Muscle biopsies were performed on
4 separate days before exercise for 1 h at 75% peakoxygen consumption
(VO2) followed by five, 1-min sprints. After the training session
on day 7, subjects ran or cycled to exhaustion at 80% peak VO2.Muscle
glycogen for cyclists and runners wasmaintained with the high-carbohydrate
diet but wasreduced 30-36% (P < 0.05) with themoderate-carbohydrate diet.All subjects completed all training sessions,and
there were no differences in times to exhaustionon day 7. For
cyclists and runners, consuming amoderate-carbohydrate diet over
7 d of intensetraining reduces muscle glycogen but has no apparent
deleterious effect on training capabilityor high-intensity exercise
performance.A high-carbohydrate diet maintains muscle glycogen,but
this has no apparent benefit on trainingcapability or high-intensity
exercise performance.
COMMENTO: Una dieta alta in carboidrati mantienele
riserve di glicogeno intatte, a differenza diuna moderata in carboidrati,
ma questo non influiscesulle prestazioni. 1/3 di glicogeno muscolare
in meno e stesse prestazioni, anche sulla prova a sfinimento.
Med Sci Sports Exerc 1998 Dec;30(12):1677-83 Effects
of high fat versus high carbohydrate dietson plasma lipids and
lipoproteins in endurance athletes. Brown RC, Cox CMDepartment
of Human Nutrition, University of Otago,Dunedin, New Zealand.rachel.brown@stonebow.otago.ac.nz PURPOSE
AND METHODS: Recent research suggestingthe performance benefits
of high fat diets forendurance athletes have been viewed with
cautionbecause of the potential negative health consequences,including
increased coronary heart disease risk.This study examined the
effects of a high fat(HF: 50% of total energy from fat, 37% carbohydrate)versus
a high carbohydrate (HC: 15% of total energyfrom fat, 69% carbohydrate)
diet on plasma lipids andlipoproteins in 32 endurance trained
cyclists overa 3-month period. Plasma total, low densitylipoprotein
(LDL), high density lipoprotein (HDL),HDL2 and HDL3 cholesterol,
triglycerides,apolipoprotein A1, and hematocrit (Hct) were measured
at baseline and after weeks 4, 8, and 12.RESULTS: Changes in lipids
and lipoproteins frombaseline to week 12 did not differ between
thetwo groups except for triglycerides, which increased significantly
from 1.04 +/- 0.17 mmol.L-1to 1.28 +/- 0.31 mmol.L-1 in HC (P
= 0.012).The only significant changes that occurred withineach
group from baseline to week 12 was thesignificant increase in
total cholesterol and triglycerides in HC.Body composition changes
did not differ betweenthe two groups from baseline to week 12
as measuredby dual x-ray absorptiometry.
CONCLUSIONS: Duringperiods of endurance training
when energyrequirements are high, increasing the percentage of
fat in the diet to approximately 50% of totalenergy didnot result
in adverse changes to theplasma lipoprotein profiles of this group
of athletes.
COMMENTO: I timori dei potenziali effetti negatividi
una dieta alta in grassi sui parametri di rischio coronarico sono
infondati. La cosa divertente è che i ricercatori, quasi vergognandosi,
passano sotto silenzio nelle conclusioni un'osservazione interessantissima
fatta precedentemente, e cioè che durante le 12 settimane di dieta,
nel gruppo ad alti carboidrati c'è un incremento significativo
del colesterolo e dei trigliceridi. Volevano dimostrare che la
dieta ad alti grassi era pericolosa, ed invece si ritrovano con
i risultati opposti, ma visto che lo scopo dell'esperimento non
era quello di dimostrare la pericolosità delle diete alte in C,
sorvolano!! spassoso ... :-)
Int J Sports Med 1998 Aug;19(6):415-8 Carbohydrate ingestion immediately before exercisedoes
not improve 20 km time trial performance in welltrained cyclists. Palmer
GS, Clancy MC, Hawley JA, Rodger IM, Burke LM,Noakes TD School
of Life Science, Kingston University,Kingston Upon Thames, Surrey,
England. This study examined the effects of carbohydrateingestion
on 20 km cycle time-trial (TT) performancein 14 well-trained cyclists
(11 males, 3 females; peakoxygen uptake [VO2peak] 4.52 +/- 0.60
l/min; valuesare mean +/- SD). All subjects performed two experimental
trials on their own bicycles mounted on an air-braked ergometry
system (Kingcycle). Subjects were instructed to maintain the same
training and dietary regimens before trials, whichwere conducted
in a random order, 3-7 days apart,and at the same time of day
for each subject. On the day of a trial, subjects reported to
thelaboratory and ingested an 8 ml/kg body mass bolusof either
a 6.8 g/100 ml commercialcarbohydrate-electrolyte (CHO) beverage
(39 +/- 4 g of CHO), or a coloured, flavoured placebo.Ten min
after finishing the drink, subjects commenceda 5 min warm-up at
150 W, before commencing the 20 km TT.The average power output
(312 +/- 40 vs 311 +/- 38 W)and heart-rate (171 +/- 6 vs 171 +/-
5 beats/min forCHO and placebo, respectively) during the two rides
did not differ between treatments. Accordingly, the performance
times for the two TT's were the same(27:41 +/- 1:39 min:sec, for
both CHO and placebo).We conclude that the ingestion of approximately
40 g ofcarbohydrate does not improve maximal cycling performance
lasting approximately 30 min, and thatcarbohydrate availability,
in the form of circulatingblood glucose, does not limit high-intensity
exercise of this duration.
COMMENTO: Ingerire una bevanda commerciale
a base di carboidrati prima dell'allenamento non serve ad un c...o!
Eur J Appl Physiol 1994;69(4):287-93 Enhanced endurance in trained cyclists duringmoderate
intensity exercise following 2 weeks adaptation to a high fat
diet. Lambert EV, Speechly DP, Dennis SC, Noakes TDLiberty
Life Chair of Exercise and Sports Science,University of Cape Town
Medical School, Observatory, South Africa. These studies
investigated the effects of 2 weeksof either a high-fat (HIGH-FAT:
70% fat, 7% CHO)or a high-carbohydrate (HIGH-CHO: 74% CHO, 12%fat)
diet on exercise performance in trainedcyclists (n = 5) during
consecutive periods ofcycle exercise including a Wingate test
of musclepower, cycle exercise to exhaustion at 85% of peak power
output [90% maximal oxygen uptake(VO2max), high-intensity exercise
(HIE)] and 50% of peak power output [60% VO2max, moderateintensity exercise (MIE)]. Exercise time toexhaustion during HIE was not
significantly different between trials: nor were the rates of
muscle glycogen utilization during HIEdifferent between trials,
although starting muscle glycogen content was lower [68.1 (SEM
3.9)vs 120.6 (SEM 3.8) mmol.kg-1 wet mass, P < 0.01] after
the HIGH-FAT diet.Despite a lower muscle glycogen content at theonset
of MIE [32 (SEM 7) vs 73 (SEM 6) mmol.kg-1wet mass, HIGH-FAT vs
HIGH-CHO, P < 0.01], exercisetime to exhaustion during subsequent
MIE wassignificantly longer after the HIGH-FAT diet[79.7 (SEM
7.6) vs 42.5 (SEM 6.8) min, HIGH-FATvs HIGH-CHO, P < 0.01].
Enhanced endurance duringMIE after the HIGH-FAT diet was associated
witha lower respiratory exchange ratio[0.87 (SEM 0.03) vs (SEM
0.02), P < 0.05], anda decreased rate of carbohydrate oxidation[1.41 (SEM 0.70) vs 2.23 (SEM 0.40) g CHO.min-1,P < 0.05].
COMMENTO: Nonostante la dieta HI-FAT portasse
ad un dimezzamento delle riserve di glicogeno muscolare (68.1
contro 120.6 mmol/kg di massa magra), la prestazione ad alta intensità
(90% VO2max) non ne veniva inficiata, e in quella a media (50%
VO2max) il tempo nella prova a "sfinimento" passava
42.5 a 79.7 minuti. META' GLICOGENO MA DOPPIA RESISTENZA ALLO
FORZO!!!
Med Sci Sports Exerc 1994 Jan;26(1):81-8 Effect
of dietary fat on metabolic adjustmentsto maximal VO2 and endurance
in runners. Muoio DM, Leddy JJ, Horvath PJ, Awad AB, Pendergast
DR Department of Physiology, StateUniversity of New York at Buffalo,
School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences 14214. The present
study examined the effects of dietarymanipulations on six trained
runners. The percentenergy contributions from carbohydrate, fat,
and protein were 61/24/14, 50/38/12, and 73/15/12 forthe normal
(N), fat (F), and carbohydrate (C)diets, respectively. Expiratory
gases and bloodresponses to a maximum (VO2max) and a prolonged
treadmill run were determined following 7 d oneach diet. Free
fatty acids (FFA), triglycerides,glycerol, glucose, and lactate
were measured.Dietary assessment of subjects' N diet indicatedthat
they were consuming approximately700 kcal.d-1 less than estimated
daily expenditures.Running time to exhaustion was greatest afterthe
F diet (91.2 +/- 9.5 min, P < 0.05) ascompared with the C (75.8
+/- 7.6 min, P < 0.05)and N (69.3 +/- 7.2 min, P < 0.05)
diets.VO2max was also higher on the F diet (66.4 +/- 2.7ml.kg-1
x min-1, P < 0.05) as compared withthe C (59.6 +/- 2.8 ml.kg-1
x min-1, P < 0.05)and N (63.7 +/- 2.6 ml.kg-1 x min-1, P <
0.05) diets.Plasma FFA levels were higher (P < 0.05) and glycerollevels
were lower (P < 0.05) during the F diet thanduring the C and
N diets. Other biochemicalmeasures did not differ significantly
among diets. These data suggest that increased availability of
FFA, consequent to the F diet, may provide forenhanced oxidative
potential as evidenced by an increase in VO2max and running time.This
implies that restriction of dietary fat may bedetrimental to endurance performance.
COMMENTO: A costo di ripetermi, la dieta alta
in grassi è quella migliore negli sport di endurance.
Metabolism 1999 Dec;48(12):1509-17 Metabolic
adaptations to a high-fat diet inendurance cyclists. Goedecke
JH, Christie C, Wilson G, Dennis SC,Noakes TD, Hopkins WG, Lambert
EVMedical Research Council/University of Capetown Bioenergetics
of Exercise Research Unit,University of Cape Town Medical School,
Newlands,South Africa. We examined the time course of metabolic
adaptationsto 15 days of a high-fat diet (HFD). Sixteenendurance-trained
cyclists were assigned randomly o a control (CON) group, who consumed
their habitualdiet (30% +/- 8% mJ fat), or a HFD group, who consumeda
high-fat isocaloric diet (69% +/- 1% mJ fat). At 5-day intervals,
the subjects underwent an oralglucose tolerance test (OGTT); on
the next day,they performed a 2.5-hour constant-load ride at 70%
peak oxygen consumption (VO2peak), followed by asimulated 40-km
cycling time-trial while ingestinga 10% 14C-glucose + 3.44% medium-chain
triglyceride(MCT) emulsion at a rate of 600 mL/h. In the OGTT,plasma
glucose concentrations at 30 minutes increased significantly after
5 days of the HFD andremained elevated at days 10 and 15 versus
the levelsmeasured prior to the HFD (P < .05). The activity
ofcarnitine acyltransferase (CAT) in biopsies of thevastus lateralis
muscle also increased from 0.45 to 0.54 micromol/g/min over days
0 to 10 of the HFD(P < .01) without any change in citrate synthase(CS)
or 3-hydroxyacyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase(3-HAD) activities. Changes
in glucose toleranceand CAT activity were associated with a shift
from carbohydrate (CHO) to fat oxidation during exercise(P <
.001), which occurred within 5 to 10 days ofthe HFD. During the
constant-load ride, the calculated oxidation of muscle glycogen
was reducedfrom 1.5 to 1.0 g/min (P < .001) after 15 days of
theHFD. Ingestion of a HFD for as little as 5 to 10 days significantly
altered substrate utilizationduring submaximal exercise but did
not attenuate the40-km time-trial performance.
COMMENTO: Il passaggio ad una dieta ad alto
contenuto di grassi provoca un adattamento metabolico, alterando l'utilizzazione
dei substrati, ovvero aumentando l'ossidazione dei grassi e diminuendo quella
del glicogeno. Questo non ha effetti negativi sulla performance.
|